Can someone help me identify a stuffed animal?

I am trying to find a replacement for this stuffed animal for my sister. It was my sister's favorite stuffed animal growing up because it was a gift from our late grandmother. I've tried looking for several weeks but since I can't identify who made this or when, I haven't been able to find a replacement.

The only other information I have is that it was purchased at an Ames department store in the mid-1990s.

Any help at all would be greatly appreciated.