answer this question

The Hunger Games Question

Why do people not like Gale?

It just seems from what I've read that most fans of the books prefer Peeta to Gale. I was just wondering, if you are one of these people, why? I personally prefer Gale. I have since book 1. It's not that I don't like Peeta, I don't love him, but I don't hate him. Gale, however, I do love. I love his character, he and Katniss are my favorite. And I hoped all the way up until the final pages that she would pick him. Peeta annoyed me multiple times in the trilogy but I never really got too upset with Gale. I think most of the reason that I love Gale is because how different he is from Peeta. He's hard, but kind, he's strong and willing but is also gentle and loving. Peeta seems to me more innocent, kinda feminine, but also sweet and caring. But I think I prefer Gale because that's who i would look for in someone, rather than Peeta's character.

But how does everyone else feel, and why do you prefer Peeta over Gale or Gale over Peeta?
*
couldn't have said it better myself
livetobefree posted over a year ago
*
you have a good point
rueyourue posted over a year ago
*
I agree with everything you said
tracytracy2000 posted over a year ago
 smitty235 posted over a year ago
next question »

The Hunger Games Answers

pasdoll said:
I totally agree with you!
I really don't understand why everyone are so fond of Peeta. Sure he's sweet and nice, but that's just it - he was too perfect. No one can be that perfect. I don't think there was a single time where Peeta done something unforgivable. I know he tried to kill Katniss, but that wasn't him, it was the venom.
Gale on the other hand isn't perfect, nor trying to be. He's strong and caring. He had to work hard for his family survival. He also fought for his belief.
I personally think most people prefer Peeta because he was so nice, and they probably liked the idea of two people falling in love in the games. I personally thought it was too obvious, but oh well. I also think most people don't like Gale because Suzanne Collins often portrayed him as an angry guy who had something against the Capitol. I really don't think she liked him very much. She definitely prefered Peeta.
And since most people like Peeta, they probably don't like the idea of Gale getting in the way of him and Katniss.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
oh my gosh! Someone who agrees with me! I voted this best answer :)
livetobefree posted over a year ago
izbia150 said:
for me why i don't like gale is every time katniss doesn't agree with him he freaks out, he's more mean and won't let katniss be close to anyone else, he thinks he's better then everyone and more deserving of katniss's love, and i could go on a whole rant about why i don't like gale but before i get to that i'll stop here
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
That's the reason i don't like Gale either!
Heroine999 posted over a year ago
*
me too
pop_lover_101 posted over a year ago
Cagirl304 said:
I really like Gale becaues he is smart and love the out doors the reasion I like him over Peeta is becoues he had to grow up with barly any food on the table but he always found a way to feed his brothers and sister unlike Peeta he always had food more or less, and I just don't like the way Peeta acts. I'm still in the middle of bool two so I don't know what happens. I have many friends who like Peeta and hate Gale for a reasion I do not now.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
same :) Gale's the best :)
livetobefree posted over a year ago
fanfangirlfan said:
I AGREE WITH EVERYTHING YOU SAID!! peetas ok but gale is AMAZING. i have, since the first book, liked gale the best. gale just seems so much more real. he comes across as much tougher than peeta but he can still be really gentle and loving with katniss. peeta barely even survived the hunger games! if gale had been in the arena with katniss he would have been much more helpful and not such a burden. i really hoped katniss would end up with gale but it was pertty predictable that she would end up with peeta. i guess they were just meant to be!
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
elstef said:
I feel like Gale was probably a decent guy, but I did have a couple of problems with him. One was that he was an obstacle to Katniss being with Peeta, and I wanted her with Peeta and am glad that they ended up together. The other problem I have is that he seems to only really be into Katniss when he sees that somebody else is into her. He admitted that he first noticed her in that way when he saw that other guy hitting on her, and then he wants her again after he sees her kissing Peeta on tv.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
i agree
izbia150 posted over a year ago
livetobefree said:
I like Gale because he's real and strong and when you get past the hard exterior, he is a loving person. People skip over all the good things he did like *spoilers* when he saved Prim in the District 13 bombing risking his own life, or when he gave Katniss his food when they didn't get much, or when even though Peeta was taking the woman he loved away he helped train him for the quarter Quell. I do not like Peeta because I think his character is very fake. I don't think any one is as perfect as him and i dont like how everyone always has to save him or look out for him. I dont think he is very manly either. Those are my opinions and they aren't changing.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
JaseKS said:
I, for one, prefer Gale, because he just seems more real to me.

The author of the book purposely gave Peeta many of Gale's traits plus more. Not only is he caring, a decent survivor, and slightly rebellious towards the Capitol, but he also is willing to lay down his life for those whom he loves, he is caring, kind-hearted, and smart.

Gale seems more real to me. He's there to survive, and he cares enough to help both his and Katniss's family while she had to go to the games. He's like most male's are, hard, but caring. His rebellious ways are amazing, and standing up to the Capitol PURPOSELY, well, that was a brave thing to do, and if I were in the book, I would be on his side. He doesn't really want anyone's help, and the love he and Katniss share was brought up by years of friendship and trusting. It's obvious they care for eachother. Wheras Katniss's so called "romance" with Peeta was made up for the press. Any love she feels for him she only feels because she was pressured too. And when someone says they're madly in love with you, it's human nature to start thinking about that person and starting to like them too, even if it's not real love.


And another thing, Peeta seems just... TOO perfect. Kind of like (pardon this reference) Edward from Twilight. His character is too fake.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
rueyourue said:
I like them both but think peeta is totally sweet. i just don't like it when people pick the guy who is hottest.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
I don't like him because he's the hottest (Although it's true and a plus!) I like him because of his character. He doesn't take crap from people, he's very selfless if you think about it, he's a good friend, he never pushed her to anything she didn't want to do. He didn't have the kind of life that Peeta did. (I know his wasn't perfect, but growing in up in a bakery is better than having to start providing food for your entire family and yourself at 13.) I find him to be a better person too, Peeta seems to fake. He gets upset over little things and pouts about them. He's just not my type. Gale, however, is ;)
smitty235 posted over a year ago
*
I think he's Hot which by the way Collins explains it he is but he has amazing qualities too. That trait
puggyluv17 posted over a year ago
*
Yeah...I agree with you.
Heroine999 posted over a year ago
puggyluv17 said:
Are you crazy. Peeta is so much better all I wanted to so through the whole series was squeeze gales head off he made me so mad. While peeta is weet and katniss needed a person like him to calm and help her through stuff. While katniss wasn't my favorite charater and I agree with hay itch when he said that she will never desere peeta. I kinda think she needed him in he end. But I don't hate gale. He made the story complete
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
xCottonCandyx said:
well i can't choose but i think the reason why people pick Peeta is because they know that she marries him in the end anyway.. but thts just my opinion so there also could be alot of other reasons
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
tdafan121 said:
I liked Gale better since the beginning. His character was more realistic than Peeta's, and I felt that Peeta's relationship with Katniss was rather fake, as it basically began with publicity.
I prefer Gale with Katniss because they have more of a history together. I've said before, Katniss and Gale remind me of Max and Fang from Maximum Ride. They've had a longer, closer relationship than Katniss and Peeta have.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
I kinda agree with that but I also think that in maximum ride fang and max should be together while in the hunger games I agree when katniss said that she doesnt need gales rage but pretax
puggyluv17 posted over a year ago
*
I agree but they did bond A LOT in the games. But I think fang and max should be together while I agree with katniss that she doesn't need gales rage but peetas kindness is what will help ber. And I think gale could fig
puggyluv17 posted over a year ago
memer676 said:
i dont know i like peeta mostly because he would risk his lif for katniss hes my kinda person gale isnt in my image i can see him as a ego dude just like jacob in twilight sooo yah gale also killed prim!! he didnt bomb it but he made the bomb so i think its obvious why i like peeta more
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
psychlover1123 said:
Well my reason is because Gale is a player and meanish in my pref, + Peeta is so so so so so so CUTE!!!
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
hoodfabulus1 said:
Okay honestly, I read a few chapters of Mockingjay and then couldn't take I any longer and skipped to when Peeta came back, so honestly I don't know much of Gale's character, he wasn't in the two books really. It's not enough for me to know of his actions, I need dialogue. And Peeta was funny, thats what really stands out to me, him licking the plate and calling out effie, and other stuff, he was essential comic relief. I didn't think he was too perfect (uh oh) and in Mockingjay I was like f he's a lot like me now... And people think he's gay ya right... I got vibes that Peeta could be selfish, in the first book at least, like if he didn't like The girl. Also I like people that can do public speaking, I like how Peeta really is the underdog and rises on top because normally types like gale take that part. And gale just a bit annoying, boring, typical, serious. I really need to read all of Mockingjay but ten bucks my opinion of him doesn't change that much. He's sweet, yes, and strong. Ok I might like both of them equally. I just like people who try really hard if anything gale was too perfect.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
next question »